H&R Block Sucks
I read about issues like this more and more. I read here and there that the gay couples who have opted to go ahead and get a "civil union", are now sorry that they made that decision. It supposedly gives you marriage equality in the state of Connecticut, IN EVERY WAY. At least, that's the bill of goods that we bought into when this state passed it's so called "civil union" bill. From the actual bill itself:
Sec. 14. (NEW) (Effective October 1, 2005) Parties to a civil union shall have all the same benefits, protections and responsibilities under law, whether derived from the general statutes, administrative regulations or court rules, policy, common law or any other source of civil law, as are granted to spouses in a marriage, which is defined as the union of one man and one woman. (source)
We don't plan on getting a civil union. We don't plan on our state or anyone else forcing us into something that's just not equal. We are happy right where we are.
So, now that tax season is upon us, we of course filed separately with the state and the federal government. It's not as if we have any options. But when Kent went to file with Tax Cut, the software we've been using for a few years now to prepare our taxes with, it had a button for information for those in "civil unions" in Connecticut. Basically, it simply stated that if you actually are in a Connecticut civil union and want to file jointly in Connecticut, you are welcome to do that, BUT, you first had to file a fake federal return pretending like you were married, so that you could indicate the federal calculation for the the state filing. You would then use that information to file the state return. Then, when you did your federal return, you would redo the whole thing separately and without the marriage calculations, since the federal government does not honor civil unions, or apparently marriage (Massachusetts) for that matter for gay couples.
Bottom line is, when Kent explained all the hoops we would have to go through to file a joint tax return in Connecticut under the civil union law, my reply was, "SCREW THAT!". Now, I'm more convinced than ever that I don't want a sham marriage that civil unions provides.
This morning, I came across this bit of information....
HARTFORD, CT – The American Civil Liberties Union sent a demand letter to H&R Block today demanding that it change its online tax preparation system to accommodate gay couples in Connecticut with civil unions. The ACLU is representing a couple with a civil union who attempted to file their taxes on the company’s website through their online service, TaxCut Online, but were told, “We don’t support Connecticut civil union returns.” Through its website, the company said the couple would have to work with one of their professionals, by phone or at one of their office locations, which would be more time consuming and substantially more expensive. (A PDF with screen captures of the messages is available at http://www.aclu.org/lgbt/relationships/34632res20080325.html)
“This is yet another example of the many ways that civil unions just don’t live up to marriage,” said Jason Smith of Hartford, who has been with his partner Settimio Pisu for six years. “It really stung when I realized it would cost an additional $150 dollars to have our tax returns prepared. We’re saving for a house and hoping to start a family, so every penny counts right now.”
According to the letter the ACLU sent to H&R Block, failing to provide gay couples with civil unions the option of filing their taxes online as it does for married couples is in violation of a state law that bars discrimination based on sexual orientation and civil union status. The letter demands that the company adapt its website to accommodate couples with civil unions and to reimburse all couples who were forced to pay the additional charges due to H&R Block’s discriminatory practices.
“The civil union law has been in effect for nearly three years now, yet companies still aren’t taking it seriously,” said Andrew Schneider of the ACLU of Connecticut. “There is no excusable reason why the company that likes to claim it’s the world’s largest tax services provider shouldn’t make its products available to everyone.” (source)
This doesn't really effect us at all. We are not part of a sham marriage called a civil union or domestic partnership, or whatever the hell you want to call it. Marriage is simply not available to us. We have accepted it and moved on. We filed separately since we have no choice. It's not clear we would be at an advantage to file jointly, but it would be nice to have the option available to us. But I do understand that there are selfish pricks amongst us who don't want to see that. That's fine I suppose. We've moved on. I simply find articles like this interesting because it really proves what I've been saying all along.
We got a lot of yard work done yesterday. It was warm, around 75 degrees. We took the opportunity to get the patio furniture out on the deck for the summer. I spent the afternoon cleaning up around the year, washing down the furniture, and grill, in preparation for dinner. I bought steak, potatoes, and vegetables for grilling. We made everything in the grill. I love grilled vegetables.
Tonight, we are having grilled chicken breasts, grilled vegetables, and fresh sour dough bread that is rising as I type this. Some months ago, we made a sour dough starter. It's really coming into its own now, and giving us some really great bread. From start to finish, a loaf of sour dough bread takes 5 hours. It's not quite as bad as all that. I let the bread machine to all the heavy work.
Along with the grilled chicken, vegetables, and bread, I'm having a peach salsa with the chicken. And along with all of that, I'll be grilling pear. I know it sounds strange, but grilled pear is really amazing. The vegetables are grilled 10 minutes, tops. The pear will only stay on the grill for a few minutes. It intensifies the flavor.
And I think I will repeat what I did yesterday. After all the yard work, I was all sweaty and hot. I took a cool shower, dressed in to summer clothes (short sleeve shirt and cut offs), and made a tall, ice cold red grapefruit margarita. Grapefruit juice and tequila. I use top shelf tequila, sipping quality. I don't skimp on the quality of any drink. If it's worth making, it's worth the best ingredients.
Well, after two of those, I could swear that it was getting cooler. :-)
I also want to say to Jeff and Moe up in Massachusetts, who got married yesterday, CONGRATULATIONS. I wish you both all the best. You make a great looking couple.
Cheers! Have a nice day.
0 TrackBacks
Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: H&R Block Sucks.
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://billandkent.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/2398




Buck,
Thank you for your **very** thoughtful comments concerning my entry about marriage. I do appreciate them because they make me think about what I've said. Sometimes, I feel like this blog is like a diary. I write... they are my thoughts at the time... who listens?
And when people read what I write and leave feedback on what I have written, good or bad, it makes me think about what I've said. So, I want to thank you for that!
I want to make something clear though. Yes, I did refer to civil unions and domestic partnerships as "sham" marriages. But, it's not you and your partner that I'm referring to. It's what our states and our nation has labeled our relationships. They have made them sham marriages by making them less than marriage. I'm speaking not of the bond that you both have for each other. Nothing could be farther from the truth. I'm talking about the extreme frustration that I feel for people like you and your partner, and Kent and myself, have to deal with because they refuse to see us as equals. THAT is the sham. Until they see us as equal, the marriage will simply not be a marriage. In simplistic terms, it's like looking at a pie, and calling it a cake. You can do that all day long but at the end of the day, it's still a pie.
I think it's actually a test, and a great testament to people like us, that we do stay together even through all of this adversity. I could write a book on what we've been through just to stay together. And I'm sure you could as well. I want us to be equal, spiritually and legally, to our straight brothers and sisters who can get legally married.
That being said, I understand what you are talking about when you speak of legal protections. My frustration is this...
In Connecticut, Kent and I can get a civil union. That would give us most of the legal state protections of real marriage, but not all. However, it would cover some major protections, such as hospital visitation and the like. The big ticket items at the federal level would not be covered, of course.
So we too are confronted with the decision of entering into a civil union, or take the risks. And the reason I call it a sham is because even here in Connecticut (we think of ourselves as "enlightened" and tolerant), there have been documented cases of partners not admitted to hospitals because there is confusion on what a civil union is. And just about the time that we decide to enter into a civil union because we have come to the conclusion that it's the best we can hope for, we read about gay couples who are now sorry that they entered into one (in Connecticut), because it's not as equal as they were promised it would be.
I suppose in time this will be ironed out (it's been in effect for 3 years now), but right now, it is a problem.
To the couples out there who have opted to enter into a civil union or domestic partnership, I wish you the very very best and I most certainly hope that it offers and delivers on legal protections for you.
I meant no disrespect of your relationships what so ever. I was simply voicing my view and the personal dilemma we face, when and if we get a civil union. I know it will offer some protection, but I don't want to walk away from my wedding feeling like I'm just not quite good enough for marriage. Maybe someday I can do that, but not yet. I think it's a personal choice that each couple must make.
The truth is, eventually, Kent and I will enter into a civil union if we must. As you stated, we will go for all the legal protections we can. And as you get older, those become more important.
Bill, I know you don't support Civil Unions because you want to see full marriage, as do all of us. However, sometimes it seems a little disrespectful to people who are trying to give their relationship some sort of footing to continually refer to their relationship as a "sham" marriage.
You've never lived in the South where even a Civil Union could be another century away and I would almost bet they'd fight another Civil War if the federal government institutes marriage equality.
People take what they can get to have some sense of stability and protection in a world that would just as soon see us disappear from the face of the earth.
A little understanding goes a long way. I'm sure you don't mean to demean their relationships and their choices but sometimes it almost reads that way.
I can promise you, Michael and I are not in a "sham" anything. We make as many legal connections as possible to prevent as many problems as possible later on in life. It's not marriage, but I know that as long as I'm in the city of Tucson, AZ no one can keep us apart in a hospital, no one can charge us "extra" because we're a same sex couple and not a "married" couple, etc. That piece of paper also gives us one more official document in our hands should anyone ever contest our wills or anything else.
I'm glad you guys are happy, and I pray you never run into a problem with anything at all. But, for the rest of us, we do what we can to protect our relationships, finances, and future plans.